Northern Star rejects sale as Elliott escalates campaign
The Australian gold miner pushed back against calls for a sale in a letter to shareholders, but Elliott argued the company's own disclosures strengthen the case for a formal strategic review.
Northern Star Resources has rejected activist investor Elliott Investment Management's call for a sale process, setting the stage for an escalating battle over the future of Australia's largest gold miner.
In a Wednesday letter to shareholders, Northern Star Chairman Michael Chaney acknowledged the company's recent share price underperformance and said that efforts to find a replacement for both himself and outbound CEO Stuart Tonkin were underway.
Chaney also noted the board was seeking new directors with “deep gold experience” and said the company would be “pleased to consider any candidates that [Elliott] might have in mind.”
However, he stopped short of embracing the activist's central demand for a strategic review that could lead to a sale of the company.
"With reference to Elliott's suggestion that the board should run a sale process for the company, we do not consider that this is the right time to do so," Chaney wrote, adding that the board had recently evaluated takeover and merger approaches, as well as potential asset spin-offs.
Ultimately though, Chaney said these options were not currently in shareholders’ best interests.
The letter marks the first time Northern Star has publicly acknowledged receiving inbound acquisition interest and reviewing structural alternatives, including asset separation proposals from advisers.
The company said such options remain under regular review but argued its focus should remain on operational improvements, leadership succession and executing its long-term strategy.
Elliott responded within hours, arguing that the board's letter effectively validated its investment thesis.
The activist argued that Northern Star’s admissions of share price underperformance and M&A considerations strengthened the case for a formal review process.
"The case for a strategic review is now more apparent than it was before the Board published its letter," Elliott said.
The activist reiterated its calls for a substantially strengthened board and a comprehensive review of all strategic options, including a standalone turnaround plan, asset separation alternatives, and a potential sale process.
The exchange follows Elliott's disclosure earlier this month that it had built a stake worth more than AUD1 billion ($715 billion) in Northern Star. The activist has argued that the company has failed to capitalize on record gold prices, citing repeated operational setbacks, guidance misses, and significant share price underperformance relative to peers.
While Northern Star has rejected a sale process for now, the company's acknowledgement that it has received takeover interest and evaluated structural alternatives gives Elliott additional ammunition as it pushes for broader strategic and governance changes.
Northern Star Resources’ stock closed at AUD18.32 on Thursday in Sydney, down 1.2% from the day before. The stock is down 25.4% year-to-date.
Like this article? Sign up for our free newsletter.


